EU Commissioner condemns Hungary’s unlawful surveillance
European Commissioner for Justice, Didier Reynders, has emphasized the importance of protecting citizens from unlawful state surveillance, both in physical reality and in cyberspace. Speaking at a plenary of the European Parliament discussing the use of spy software, Reynders condemned interference in private communication, stating that it goes against democratic values and infringes upon fundamental rights.
The European Commission expects all member states to thoroughly review reports on the use of spy software to ensure compliance with the law and to prevent any unlawful activities. In cases where the software is deployed unlawfully, Reynders stressed the importance of providing victims with the opportunity for legal redress.
However, not all member states are adhering to these principles. Sándor Rónai, an MEP from the opposition Democratic Coalition (DK), criticized the Orbán government for its treatment of spy software. Rónai claimed that the government’s actions have resulted in high inflation, withheld EU funds, and soaring food prices in Hungary. He further accused the government of targeting independent media by surveilling them with spy software, suggesting a violation of the rule of law.
Katalin Cseh, an MEP from the Momentum party, also expressed her disapproval of European states using military software for the surveillance of journalists. She called for joint action and clear regulation to address this issue. Cseh also criticized ministers who evade tough questions by isolating themselves.
It is evident that there are varying opinions within the European Parliament regarding the use of spy software. While Commissioner Reynders stresses the need for protection against unlawful state surveillance, opposition politicians like Rónai and Cseh raise concerns about governments potentially abusing spy software and violating fundamental rights. The debate highlights the importance of establishing clear regulations and safeguards to prevent misuse and protect citizen privacy.
[Featured image: illustration]
